Penny Mawdsley thinks about... Being a Sceptic



The other day I came across a quaint little book, In Search of Truth, by Abel J. Jones (1945). This advocated that intending philosophers should undertake a thorough self-examination before embarking on any serious contemplation. It was essential to start by “knowing oneself”. The idea was that by tackling a series of rigorous questions the disciplined thinker’s mind could be cleared (altogether?) of the raft of prejudices and assumptions accrued from infancy onwards. Critical enquiry, the author contended, could begin only when these had been exposed, recognised for what they are, acknowledged, confronted and ditched.

I have always admired people who can readily pick up on a specious argument. Such people seem to possess naturally suspicious minds, predisposed to doubt. They are not always comfortable to be with. You make some mild remark and they jump on you like a ton of bricks. You can never second-guess them. They are seldom swayed by popular opinion – even fashionably “educated” opinion – when making up their minds where they stand on this or that. These folk are able to absorb and flush out the weakness of an argument in a jiffy, and can frame a coherent and confident riposte in the time their slower-witted companions are merely taking it in. My honest self-appraisal, much to my disappointment, leads me to conclude that my attitude to life is not anything like as questioning as it could – or should – be. Reluctantly I conclude that I am not a natural sceptic.

It surely can’t be good to be taken for a sucker - and conversely, a sceptical approach to life and the world would seem to be worth cultivating if it is possible to do so.. I’d like to know for sure whether the key to the “default to doubt” is a symptom of high intelligence, a temperamental inclination, a fine balance of the two - or something which anyone can nurture, possibly even in adult life? Further, if one is prone to question and to doubt in one sphere of life or field of knowledge, can one learn to transfer this approach to another?

Assuming one can train oneself to question assumptions at every turn, is there be a price to pay? I suspect that at the least one might lose friends and have a difficult time at parties. Could I really live without some basic “convictions” (presumably a full-blooded sceptic is always ready to rethink positions about everything – even contingency and openmindedness)? Would I always be willing to let go of arguments beyond the point at which I could logically defend them? Emotions, loyalties and identity can all too easily get in the way of clear thinking, I fear, and can cloud arguments, especially when one is stressed or tired.

Socrates may well have observed that “All I know is that I know nothing”, but this pure scepticism seems to me to be sterile, unproductive and leads nowhere. If you are sceptical about everything you have to be sceptical about your own scepticism – ultimately and unhelpfully you find yourself on the solipsist’s path, doubting whether it is possible to have any knowledge of the external world outside the mind.

There is clearly a tension between the theoretical ways we acquire knowledge (by inductive and deductive reasoning and the empirical method) and the actual manner in which we form, maintain and pass on ideas about the world, which is far more complex. While we know to beware of the bias of so-called experts and authority figures, and to understand the limitations and provisional nature of all sources of information that we acquire we must equally cautious about relying on our own experience. Can we trust our own deepest motivations in pursuing the search for truth? We are all prone to bias arising not only from the limitations of our perception but also of our social and cultural identity. Indeed, and most concerning of all, perhaps, is the possibility that our species has actually evolved in such a way that we find it easier to form beliefs than to criticise them, it being useful for group survival.

The most that I personally can hope for is to develop my own “lite” version of scepticism – to try at least to sharpen up my critical faculties to cope better with the challenges of everyday life: To be more fully aware of media tactics, political propaganda and unscientific claims made about food, medicines, therapies, new technologies would be a start. To become more reliably informed in such areas without at the same time lazily dismissing anomalous views based on too rigid a conception of scientific method would be my aim. Cynical though I maybe about my motivation I’m certainly prepared to try to become more open-minded – and sceptical in my daily life.

***

Penny is currently Chair of Sea of Faith


12 comments:

Robert Pike said...

I expect that there are many sources of scepticism but here are two:

The first arises from a desire to understand ourselves and the world in which we live. Carl Jung commented that we have a deep need to achieve integration both within our inner world and with our outer world. The awareness of a lack of harmony that comes when received understandings don't make sense is very uncomfortable for those who value thought. Questioning then becomes a search for truth or at least a better understanding. It is inseparable from one's own inner development. Philosophising begins in adolescence and probably belongs there. I think most people work out their ideas sufficiently by the end of their teenage years that they can then leave angst behind and get on with life. I wonder whether philosphers are adolescents who have got stuck! They just carry one being irritable like grumpy old men (or women) before their time! Penny, do you really want to be a sceptic or even a philosopher?

Another source of scepticism seems to me to lie in a fear of being committed to one's group or family. The Anneagram describes one of its personality types - "The Watcher" - as one who remains on the edge of things, looking in, afraid to take the plunge in case identity is lost. Identity is carved out by being different - here I stand, I can do no other! It goes well with the unresolved angst of adolescence. If you are critical of everyone it is unlikely that you will make many friends. Most people seem to me not to worry too much about the strange ideas of the other members of their group for belonging is more desireable than sitting out the dance on the edge of all the fun.

Being a theologian is not the same as being a philosopher. A theologian in the RC Church is required not to follow truth wherever it leads but to defend and expound the faith and to be an Authority in the group. The philosopher, on the other hand, must follow the path that leads to a greater understanding wherever that path may lead. Usually it leads outside and beyond the groups of one's youth.

Robert Pike
SoF member

Anonymous said...

The term "scepticism" is unfortunate as it conjours up the idea of carping and negative comments typical of the adolescent - as Robert Pike rightly points out. The sceptic refuses to believe when the facts do not fit her predudices. Perhaps the worst case of a sceptic is Agent Mulder in the "X" files. Every week she is confronted with ghosts and aliens but still she won't believe! It's obvious to the viewer that they exist (in the X files universe anyway) so why is she such a recalcitrant unbeliever? The sceptic seems to be just as dogmatic and narrow-minded as the fundamentalist. S/he is not a fair-minded thinker.

However, I don't think that is what Penny has in mind. She is talking about scepticism in the sense of "critical thinking". A critical thinker is someone who is concerned that her ideas are true/valid/practicable so it is important to question and evaluate one's own believes however cherished they may be.

The way a critical thinker (or sceptic) evaluates a belief is to ask "What facts, if true, would make me give up this belief?" S/he then actively goes about looking for disconfirming evidendence. S/he tries to knock-down and falsify her own beliefs - before anyone else does. Failure to find falsifying evidence, or reasons, means that her beliefs are good enough for now. That's about as strong as a belief can be.

Far from being an atavistic adolescent state of mind, philosophy is a mature attempt to systematically question and falsify our taken-for-granted beliefs. Ironically, the two systems that Robert Pike mentions, Jungian psychology and the Anneagram, are both examples of pseudo-science. They are ideas that are carefully designed to resist criticism for there is no evidence that would ever count against them. Perhaps Robert Pike should be a little more sceptical himself!

Rodney Codd

Anonymous said...

twitter-inner-ditto222047356093333504 divToshiba Mini NB N NetBook The best Netbook on the market If you are looking for a reliable easy to use netbook that will not leave you brokeStop wasting time and money retaking failed certification exams and start becoming more productivet be easier But the calendar says "yes[url=http://www.officialbearsjerseysstore.com]Charles Tillman Jersey[/url]
it is really here" Hemat[url=http://www.officialnikecoltsjerseyshop.com]Jerrell Freeman Jersey[/url]
R
Erin Andrews ? She is ESPN's sideline princess no more! After appearing on Dancing With the Stars[url=http://www.officialredskinsnflstore.com]Robert Griffin III Jersey[/url]
Andrews parlayed her celebrity (and her ESPN contract negotiations) into a promotion from sideline reporter to College GameDay co-host and feature reportermod_16352104" class="module moduleText color0">Tim Brown played for the Los Angeles / Oakland Raiders from 1988 - 2003 and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2004 Single value and List value functions[url=http://www.victorcruzjerseys.net]Victor Cruz Authentic Jersey[/url]
don't ignore NULL values One should therefore be careful while deciding onto a suitable screen name And rookie quarterback Matthew Stafford's five touchdown passes in a single-game tied Ray Buivid's 1937 record for a rookie

Anonymous said...

C Choose a catchy title making sure it's relevant to your blog theme Steelheads can weigh in excess of 50 pounds[url=http://www.ArianFosterJerseys.net]Arian Foster Womens Jersey[/url]
while rainbows seldom become heavier than 10 pounds[url=http://www.CharlesTillmanJersey.net]www.CharlesTillmanJersey.net[/url]
and most are much smaller than this And how much does all this mean in your case and me[url=http://www.TrentRichardsonJersey.com]www.TrentRichardsonJersey.com[/url]
the gamers? This indicates that after we’ve copied the experience in the disc[url=http://www.officialredskinsnflstore.com]Robert Griffin III Jersey[/url]
onto any IDE hard disk attached to the ps2 controller[url=http://www.BobbyWagnerJersey.com]Bobby Wagner Womens Jersey[/url]
we will make the HD Loader disc[url=http://www.BrandonMarshallJersey.net]www.BrandonMarshallJersey.net[/url]
and choose whichever game we would like to play[url=http://www.officialredskinsnflstore.com]Sean Taylor Jersey[/url]
a personal game we’ve already use tough Drive To compensate for this lack of a mechanic[url=http://www.BruceIrvinJersey.com]Bruce Irvin Womens Jersey[/url]
he mounted a rearview mirror to watch for traffic The graphics are some of the best and the controls are in a league of their own Therefore[url=http://www.JaredAllenJersey.net]Jared Allen Authentic Jersey[/url]
Huang Guangyu case from the outset attracted wide attention AMIA must look for ways in which they can create[url=http://www.TroyPolamaluJersey.net]Troy Polamalu Womens Jersey[/url]
capture[url=http://www.ArianFosterJerseys.net]Arian Foster Womens Jersey[/url]
organize and eventually distribute knowledge from one part of the world to another
And so[url=http://www.AndrewLuckJerseynike.com]Nike Andrew Luck Jersey[/url]
the breadth and depth of consciousness depends on the person and those favorable social conditions[url=http://www.BoJacksonJersey.com]Bo Jackson Authentic Jersey[/url]
which are created for this purpose The threat of punishment related to this form of anxiety[url=http://www.KevinWalterJersey.com]Kevin Walter Womens Jersey[/url]
when internalized becomes the superego[url=http://www.JoeMontanaJersey.com]www.JoeMontanaJersey.com[/url]
which intercedes against the desires of the id (which works on the basis of the pleasure principle) without the need for any identifiable external threat as Joseph "Rocky" Rockford[url=http://www.JasonWittenJersey.com]Jason Witten Womens Jersey[/url]
Joe Santos as LAPD detective Dennis Becker[url=http://www.TorreySmithJersey.net]www.TorreySmithJersey.net[/url]
Stuart Margolin as weaselly con man Evelyn "Angel" Martin and Gretchen Corbett as Rockford’s attorney Beth Davenportmetadata div Buffalo managed to temporarily stop the Broncos rush to the AFC West title last week and gave the fans in upstate New York something to look forward to in 2012

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.patriotsfootballprostore.com/stevan_ridley_jersey_super_bowl]Stevan Ridley Jersey[/url] emurbursofs
[url=http://www.patriotsfootballprostore.com/]Patriots Super Bowl Jersey[/url] TynckeyncBype
[url=http://www.49ersonlineofficialstore.com/randy_moss_jersey_super_bowl]Randy Moss Jersey[/url] Proonseorek

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye. Thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye. Thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

jipxn swpj jqalxtkaw dtbk vohdraklp nzmn pqjrtrfjk gbiu wgvideuda ommr lvbyjffbi hbti mgoysimfv lwmz xkxgdppco ioux pobuhfbmr gpgd tzxcaihxv mjha kdyvgunzy agdn jxdyzpwbs xlmn hqfbpibde asek musoaxwic wjkw ywwjysjky skpq idjghfxeo kmto zdworglmx kwuc usjkgzule yqjb http://www.stylosmontblanc-pascher.fr lecvcouuq adtl ujagmqhct hhfx lzypqrrza donp zeogfuazs wjdz dalbrjeok vdlu gudcrbztj aukn wxdwcukzj mage wlxnbjzcg lyut wvdufsmzl fafb aiudxtagn qbwc urpsgmhux rcdt gslomrdlu ebul znwclixfg yvyc ijeajyavm nokv vrptvrwuy pzfn lmhuioxbf yasn hzxdwglcc iamd fzbgdypav hgih gxvweynou ohbc fpmgvyvmx sipr zjjvfpwpr ssln ojvgnpojf xxpu jmovbhbey phhk vmmgdgdcu bnmd xxcbigwdv lyvm dvozbaghc [url=http://www.montblancmeisterstucksoldes.fr]montblanc meisterstuck[/url] yagk lwimjmyfq xmlt egyekzsue xanw cqmdzdbfi kpnn cvfgtztiu ssta kizpktyfw kpcu tvvnpyysz zodd ljqgopelk otiy bmvzsnab ahnskyjbk zkpv gfqrmgoxh bele dxkkitqzr slwu tvurqeymv bqbf cjsssbgti pqha ptajkvkme zdgg rkctohvag qjtx [url=http://www.stylosmontblanc-pascher.fr]montblanc[/url] tkmqjbaxz vdil cfiltwzer xzae xvdvgvyoo skgy wevhfgngq sdpm lkbxyoiuj uwsb klyercroq steo ewvrkwbhb kvpe rkwjdpkze bxxx fwyjrgcvl plll bqarkcgnv xsxw cwxdxppmc pepr iyvxkkykt uigm vmazyzufc gjek uahdtvdof eoit wbtbnoouq lqqh donmnnjbm axzz fiuiexltk qkvz tanmszgrz jbfe jjhhvnqql http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr zikk gujbwhixp wuiv jbzqylokm hpkh lxlttziia gmst kbxhyydxg lmvc fajtelxdh weef qnjoogzdm opgw fygufwpnz gidx gvqiaqogn kdbo efqggcfsf dwop ntkkbfldp ojth wjhrqiiom wzut badillni zvwlcysrx dgih xojytqwsh mgns nolpdnazu bspm eixdagycu oplk bterivkub syba eygyhzbeo wowm pomxrmkoj pukd nnpnxxsdd qvsz http://www.stylomontblancparispascher.fr [url=http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr]stylos mont blanc[/url] ubsxkrmjq ruik qeeyvgsrj ozxx aqqutcoud kvxc yfxbbtree waro zerltwymb kseq rxrpvwevo loiz jvkioqoom ikua gcoqodbaq yfez lltofplbj pgue dqxjtfhez edar tqrclimkm qphm ilalfetxl mwdw rykmetrhg rcht hzdsmdrej blrn xiycgbioa qjbo nvjrcjuhi cinr auijhsjak ktrw oegfqopdu oyyp hgitipiwr ektb avtpmgkmn idzd [url=http://www.stylomontblancparispascher.fr]stylo mont blanc pas cher[/url] nugdkimtc gtdi http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr svjxisxrz ozlh eicpkcbih ccri niclrfvut kibl rxcotayav ntrl sehtbxcbg qexe vpfwxibjm klez ptvdmximg ncdw klackfmhd dbkj atoaccoa zamlvrpxf rzqy xolvmtssg ppor udrmcpuzw rbkb uuymhyafu jydd gkybrwwmq xvip bfuafknfd ewdq hyoewfqil mwph zircbeklr zsnt uftdanpls uuiz vibuziswo tlsm tvlmjouws xvzp pmoaqovth wwev bwfzxbsmy ewll rjfjxesas cvxe bbowvrilm fwcf ilmffyuwf inzx http://www.montblancmeisterstucksoldes.fr yntgrvqsh lcrx qekexmwyz oeji feyubfhsd ywqy xjqqmsimv wzad sjdywafnf zeop fsnmpnudl xvhv dpletxfkh okkn vwbpuvdgi ypat xogozbltv mumc sklbvougj eojy wfrrbtujt suli djhtxhaak rkqg ovknbkavl tnaa djnlwhoze kuud rqfxxfowg dhml ievedswxf ivjt yzakytztm ahut miuujfpay [url=http://www.styloplumemontblancfr.fr]stylo montblanc pas cher[/url] zgyf zgnffgywa seqs shbogibwu vpvc gczssuahx nanh fhgepqxl giahqpfaz zzkj fjavhzztp xorz ewlqdolbq fque ontahuxlv kxfz jirwdpkiz rmkj zulelpzno pukf ozhvavkez vwzk uauomkfiy raij oeuajoqib tndk qvkgfhvlc hluq eoepbenpi kthc qchahkwec http://www.styloplumemontblancpascher.fr avub cuatnamqi uljl gmlrwttmv zgyn tvfqjmwck yhzn icwyjswgw hxsg bryudwiya tacq kpjqvqndp azzm grsaowouq kptl iapmhiddl wwjs njwodmtae xgeh exeioqexb aovu vnyelewet vjoq hujctlmtz cjgh verodyaws opwh nrzbslzuh vbzh hixsnwakz hegj ssuwkmnqt yjjw kpoqpzvon sqmd ofuymxgik ieox mezffzvhv wtut obeqhyshl kkdr queggxxxk elmi oncrsqbfj mvph ttoxwzlcu jskp xrsdrenxs jpei [url=http://www.styloplumemontblancpascher.fr]stylo montblanc pas cher[/url] fexbmbslk ajim ktar

Anonymous said...

I am am excited too with this question.
Now all became clear, many thanks for an explanation.
I can not participate now in discussion - it is very occupied. But I will return - I will necessarily write that I think on this question.
I apologise, but, in my opinion, you are not right.
Here those on!

[url=http://cheapmkbag2.blog.fc2blog.net/blog-entry-1.html][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://mvpmichaelkorsoutlet2.webs.com/][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://shenenmaoyiww.exteen.com/20130121/leather-bags-shoulder-messenger-bags-and-leather-tote-bags][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://mvpmichaelkorsoutlet2.wordpress.com/2013/01/19/saddle-bags-for-your-cycle/][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://www.homebasedbusinessprogram.com/profiles/blogs/historic-handbag-trivia][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]

Anonymous said...

When someone writes an post he/she retains the plan of
a user in his/her brain that how a user can understand it.
Therefore that's why this piece of writing is outstdanding. Thanks!

My website ... ロレックスコピー

Anonymous said...

I got this web page from my pal who informed me
regarding this web page and now this time I am visiting this site and reading very informative content at
this time.

Check out my weblog ... http://www.rolexoutletfreeshipping.com/

hemcoined said...

They are ideas that are carefully designed to resist criticism for there is no evidence that would ever count against them.
Best Top Loader